Monday, October 20, 2008

20 October 2008 COALESCENCE

Today we met and discussed the article:

Richards CL, BC Carstens & LL Knowles. (2007). Distribution modelling and statistical phylogeography: an integrative framework for generating and testing alternative biogeographical hypotheses." Journal of Biogeography 34:1833-1845.

The article concerned the use of historical patterns and climate data to create better models for determining the phylogeography of organisms. Basically the method boiled down into three steps:

1) Using current distribution and layers of GIS data to determine ecological niche
2) Obtaining historical GIS data to determine the distribution of appropriate ecological niches in the past
3) Using coalescent modelling to test hypotheses generated by the previous two steps.

The first question we addressed was: What is coalescent modelling?

COALESCENT MODELS

Nadir mentioned that LAMARC (Likelihood analysis with metropolis algorithm using random coalescence) as the software that can be used to do coalescent analyses. He recommends two articles, one by Kingman (2000): "Anecdotal, Historical and Critical Commentaries on Genetics (Edited by James F. Crow and William F. Dove) Origins of the Coalescent: 1974–1982" and one by Kuhner and Smith (2007): "Comparing Likelihood and Bayesian Coalescent Estimation of Population Parameters."


We also discussed how to obtain GIS layers for historical climate data. Nadir mentioned ECOCHANGE as a possible manner in which to get that data for Europe, a project that strives to use "a range of advanced modelling approaches....to assess the impact of global change on biodiversity and ecosystems."

Please feel free to send me information about any of this and I will be happy to add it to the blog.


Tuesday, March 25, 2008

24 March 2008

It has been a while since I posted (or we met!) but a new year is underway and we should continue on. We have had a visitor to the site who had the following question:

Emily: I have a question about the gap handling. How can we deal with the gaps in ML or NJ methods. In the blog you said that "Only in Parsimony methods can this be automatically done (as a 5th or 21st option for nucleotide and amino acids respectively). "?

Nadir was good enough to offer a response:

Hi, Dealing with gaps in distance methods is possible but implies that you do not consider any model of evolution, but simply compute a similarity/distance matrix. Jaccard distances are fine to build a distance matrix (you might further use neighbor.exe [Phylip package] to construct your NJ tree). Regarding ML, Felsenstein has developed restML, a module within the Phylip package, able to deal with restriction fragments.

Since a gap can be seen - theoretically - as a potentially polymorphic site for restriction enzymes, it is possible to run restML on a matrix of presence/absence of gaps. However, Felsenstein's algorithm assumes a fixed length of the restriction site (eg, 5 nucleotides), which is very unlikely to be the case when considering different gap regions. If you want to perform analyses on gaps using a probabilistic algorithm, I would rather suggest to consider the use of MrBayes (you can define a gap matrix as being of the type datatype=restriction).